Quick Search

Advanced Search

All Our Ads

A Multiparty System has Never Existed in the Gambia and “Agenda 2011” may just be Another Utopian Idea.

By Jerry Jallow, Manchester

Over the past year or so, the opposition parties in the Gambia have been engaged in a discourse aimed at to the best to remove the APRC from power in the forthcoming 2011 elections and at the minimum to create a multiparty system in the Gambia. However, this could fail as the two main opposition parties are engaged in finger pointing politics rather than a constructive dialogue, shallow and dishonest analysis of their failures in past elections, and the lack of organisational structures (this applies to all political parties Africa). Hence “Agenda 2011” is doomed to fail. Using empirical evidences, albeit from Western democracies, this article would argue that a multiparty system has indeed never existed in Gambia’s political history. Building on that, I want to add my voice to the current debate between PDOIS and the UDP over whom to blame for their shortcomings in the 2006 elections by offering assessable questions in my analysis.

Let us consider what a “multiparty system” is. Multiparty system is a system where more than one party has the potential and ability to win and govern in a country. It also implies that two or more parties are capable of influencing the outcome of policies adopted in parliament and thus act as a check on the incumbent party. For a country to have a multiparty system, the opposition parties have to be able to some extent influence and contribute towards national and foreign policies of the country. Although the agenda or the final words maybe decided by the ruling party, but major parties are involved in the discourse leading to the adoption of these policies. Typical examples would be the Obama Healthcare Reform in which a bipartisan approach is applied or the Parliamentary Committees in the British House of Parliament or the proportional representations in Germany and Scandinavia. All these provide instances were oppositions parties are part (more or less) in the policy discourses. PDOIS, the UDP, NRP, and GMC are so remote from the legislation circles that their existence is not felt by Gambians or by the government.    

Impunity was the order of the day in the First Republic and still is today due to the lack of opposition parties with the ability to lead and represent the helpless Gambian population. These parties lack distinguished campaign managers, PR representatives, youth wings, and most importantly, almost never held press briefings or conferences. Without established institutional practices, an entity can hardly be called a political party. Bertrand de Jouvenel defined politics as ‘the capacity to bring into being a stream of wills: to canalise the stream and regularise and institutionalise the resulting cooperation’ (1958: 29). The PPP was an oligarchy with Jawara as the leader. The APRC is a one man show where Jammeh perfectly sits like Stalin as the sacred leader. PDOIS suffer similar factors as the party is solely associated with Halifa, Sedia and Sam. The UDP is like the PPP, a party of the few with Darboe as the leader. The NRP is categorically about Hamat Bah. And the story goes on, and on.

As always these entities never attempted to institutionalise their organisations and as a result when the leader disappears or is weak, the party crawls to its knees. Thus the entity is much easier to discredit and destabilise by opponents. The PPP, NCP and GPP are typical examples here. Division of labour and the coordination of efforts is a pivotal part of any entity as the continuous prosperity is dependent on it as the supportive will of others are orchestrated towards a common goal. Future leaders are schooled and nurtured to carry forward the seeds of the organisation. It also helps generate funds for the maintenance of the entity. Gambian political parties lack these features and this is manifested in the “Agenda 2011” discourse.

How can this agenda be realised when the two major camps (PDOIS and UDP) are engaged in a finger pointing campaign against each other instead of looking at the bigger picture? How honest are these two camps to themselves or to the Gambian voters? I want to answer these questions by examining what has so far transpired in the media.

The dissolution of NADD can be attributed to many different failures on all parties involved. First, Halifa should be honest to acknowledge his shortcomings as the Chair of the Execute Steering Committee. As a chairperson, your responsibility is to stream the wills of the different parties involved so that a compromise could be reached. Halifa as chairperson failed in achieving that. First, he avoided responsibility by refusing to accept being the flag bearer. To further complicate things he and Waa Juwara advocated for a primary election to be held to choose the candidate. How could that happen in a country where people are persecuted for just speaking your mind at the village bantaba much more to openly sympathise with opposition parties? I believe Halifa has to accept that he did fail in that aspect.

Two issues that struck me most were: one, the way Halifa approached the debate and his “spilling of the beans” and two: how both parties approached the analysis of the 2006 elections. In the heated debate, Halifa revealed his dealings with other individuals during past elections. He adduced that he had sponsored a candidate who still have not paid back his money. The appropriateness of this matter in the media is a cause of concern for me as a person. This may damage his credibility and trust among political partners as no one would like such issues that were handled in confidence to be revealed to the whole world.

Rather than an in-depth and honest analysis of the 2006 elections, both parties decided to apply a shallow, basic and meaningless one. As a sociologist, Halifa should have done better than just asking one “why” question. Instead a better approach from both sides would have asked “how” and “why” questions over and over again to answer why they failed. The question of voter apathy in the Gambia cannot just be explained by the single answer that ‘the opposition parties were divided’. Analytical tools such as “fish bone chart”, “minding mapping”, or a simple “brainstorming” session would reveal a lot problems with the last election.

Now I am not suggesting that things are simply done. Am aware that the political conditions are not favourable, but that is what political parties are for- to shape and change the political landscape of a country. And a better way of doing that is to institutionalise your party and its practices. This will boost your credibility among voters and within the international community.

Jerry Jallow, Manchester     


Comments (2)

suwaibou Touray
Said this on 4-14-2010 At 09:26 am

Dear editor,

As a member pf the PDOIS Party, I feel compelled to react to one Jerry Jallow’s article entitled “A Multiparty System has Never Existed in the Gambia and “Agenda 2011” may just be Another Utopian Idea”.

Interestingly enough, Mr. Jallow may not know that he has already answered his own question without knowing it. I just want to say that because of the fact that a multi-party system has never existed in the Gambia is all the more reason why the need for Agenda 2011. When a country reaches a stage as Gambia did, only the combined strength of all those who are patriotic, sincere and desire change can put that country on the right track.

I’m glad that Mr. Jallow has accepted and recognises the unfavourableness of the political landscape that exists in country. Now because of that, Agenda 2011 is simply calling all genuine political elites to this time submit themselves to the people so that the people alone shall chose the flag bearer who shall singly stand to contest for CHANGE to come about in 2011. It is simply saying, look, let all the parties go and tell the people to unite as one and be ready to shoulder their constitutional responsibility to choose the flag bearer who shall carry out a transition to DEMOCRACY without prejudice.

For democracy to come to Gambia, three things must now be entrenched, ie. 1. There must be a term limit, 2. There must be a second round of voting if no one has majority in the first round and 3. The members of the IEC must have tenure of office and it must be guaranteed by law and practice.

So Mr. Jallow we are in a catch 22 situation. There cannot be democracy unless we change the government in place since the government in place will not change the laws they put in place that secures them from change. You see the government in place cannot be changed by a single party because the laws in place do not create a free Multi-party environment conducive for such a contest.

This is why Agenda 2011 is calling on parties to forget their programs and unite the people under one umbrella and give chance to them to select their flagbearer in a simple primary and support that candidate alone so that the country can experience a transition to a genuine Multi-party democracy. Are you in anyway suggesting that this is utopian? I dont think so. I think this is democracy at its best.

What is important at this stage I think is for all those who cherish change to ask themselves whether the Agenda is a practical one or not. And if one is convinced, one should add your voice in helping your party and others to understand what one has understood and to also help inform the people. This is a more positive way of making one’s contribution than casting scepticism all over the place. Those who do that do not desire change.

You have already said all that needs to be said. The Gambian people are tired of what is happening and they don’t like it. They tell you this all over the place. They tell you they feel helpless and they need to see a way out. So if we write, let us know that people are on the ground struggling under all odds to inform the ordinary voter to have the understanding so as to bring about the desired change and they are doing it for all of us. So let’s not trivialize things. What is expected of us as genuine elites is to put constructive ideas that will help us forge ahead and not say things that would draw us back.

I have gone across the country and Agenda 2011 is appealing to all and sundry irrespective of political affiliation. The people don’t see any hidden agenda in this. They are told that it is their exclusive domain to select the flag bearer. So it’s very clear that if all genuine Gambians who desire change unite and do this, the majority of the grassroots voters will certainly take part in the election convinced that CHANGE has indeed come.

The analysis you are reacting to have been made at the time only to show the people that one party alone cannot do it under its ticket and program. And so therefore what is desirable is to have a non-party transition program entirely owned by a sovereign people who must be enlightened to understand that only them have the power to effect genuine change for their country. So please note that Agenda 2011 is for you and me.

Thank you

Suwaibou Touray.

PDOIS member

 

Reply to this Comment
Kristy
Said this on 4-20-2011 At 04:07 pm
sLqrxF Very true! Makes a change to see smoeone spell it out like that. :)
Reply to this Comment
Post a Comment
* Your Name:
* Your Email:
(not publicly displayed)
Reply Notification:
Approval Notification:
Website:
* Security Image:
Security Image Generate new
Copy the numbers and letters from the security image:
* Message:
Click here for a list of HTML tags permitted in comments

Recent News

Gambia's President Jammeh dissolves cabinet: state media

  • News Item
  • February 3, 2012

ANJUL (Reuters) - Gambian President Yahya Jammeh has dissolved his entire cabinet two months after securing re-election for a new five-year term, state broadcaster GRTS announced on Thursday. 

The brief announcement did not say why Jammeh had taken the decision or when the cabinet would be replaced. It said the president had commended his ministers for their patriotism and hard work. 

Former military coup leader Jammeh scored a landslide 72 percent victory in November to extend his 17 year-rule over the tiny West African country, which attracts thousands of Western tourists to its white-sand beaches and tropical forests. 

The African Union said Jammeh had benefited from a strong media bias and greater financial resources than rivals.

Although he has presided over a period of stability, a number of former allies have been accused of plotting coup bids during his rule.

Feb. 7 is National Black HIV/AIDS Awareness Day

  • News Item
  • February 2, 2012

Minnesota Department of Health

News Release

Feb. 7 is National Black HIV/AIDS Awareness Day

Free HIV testing and public awareness events scheduled in Minnesota

National Black HIV/AIDS Awareness Day (NBHAAD) will be held in Minnesota, as across the nation, on Feb. 7 to call attention to the staggering toll HIV/AIDS has had on Black communities across the country.

With the national theme of, "I Am My Brother/Sister's Keeper: Fight HIV/AIDS," local organizers hope to raise awareness and encourage African-Americans and African-born persons to get tested, get educated, get treated and get involved within their communities to halt the spread of this disease.

"We are emphasizing the importance of getting tested for HIV and getting into care if infected," said Peter Carr, manager of the STD and HIV Section, Minnesota Department of Health (MDH). "New studies show that HIV transmission rates can be reduced by 96 percent when infected persons get into care and treatment. As part of this year's observance, local agencies will be offering free HIV testing."

The Gambia: Civil Society Associations Gambia (CSAG) opens for business

  • News Item
  • February 1, 2012

CCG.jpg

 

By Mathew K Jallow

 

Civil Society Associations-Gambia, a coalition of seven Gambian civil and human rights organizations spread across Europe, the United States and West Africa has been launched after a year of online meetings and dozens of conference calls between founding members. The purpose of CSAG is to challenge the impunity with which the Gambian state has subjected innocent citizens to the most egregious rights abuses, which include extra-judicial executions, murders, tortures, forced disappearances, and the pervasive arrests, detentions and incarcerations. To more effectively execute its responsibilities, a new executive was elected to manage the affairs of the organization for a period of two years.  The new executive comprises: Banka.jpg

 

i.                    Banka Manneh; Chairman, US

ii.                  Ndey Tapha-Sosseh; Secretary General, Mali

iii.                Yaya Dampha; Treasurer, Sweden

iv.                Abdoulie Jobe; Member, UK

v.                  Alieu Ceesay; Member, Scotland, UK

vi.                Buba Baldeh; Member, Senegal

vii.              Mathew K. Jallow; Member, US Ndey.jpg

 

Following the election a new executive, and after extensive and exhaustive consultations, CSAG launched a website to facilitate the gathering and dissemination of information in timely manner. Readers will notice that over the past few weeks, CSAG put out press releases and public notices in line with the organization’s commitment to the restoration of the rule of law in The Gambia. So far, CSAG has sought to network with like-minded regional and international rights organizations to more broadly involve the wider international community in the effort to put the spotlight on the atrocities perpetrated by the Gambian regime. CSAG recognizes the difficult challenges confronting the Gambia and, therefore, values the working relationships so far established and continue to establish with other regional and international rights organization.

Hand in health And Books For Africa Two NGOs In MN to Send up to Million Books to Gambia!

  • News Item
  • January 30, 2012

Dear Editor,

I am a board member of Hand In Health (HIH – handinhealth.org), a Minnesota based NGO. Hand In Health has been supporting health and education in The Gambia since 2006. In 2010 HIH provided 7500 medical books for the hospital library in Bwiam.

Hand In Health is partnering with Books For Africa, (BFA - booksforafrica.org) with a goal of ending the book famine in The Gambia. Together we will send one million school and reading books to The Gambia and build up to six regional libraries, over a 3 to 5 year period. BFA and HIH raised funds for two 40ft containers of over 44,000 school and library books for The Gambia. This shipment left Atlanta 3 weeks ago and is due in Banjul by early February 2012. 

Succinct Review of the Weekly News; Dr. Janneh's Conviction And More!

  • News Item
  • January 29, 2012

By Mathew K Jallow

 

Dr. Amadou S Janneh conviction

 

For once, the cynics proved me wrong. I admit. It was just that given the extraordinary amount of unsubstantiated prosecutorial evidence, I felt that no judge could find grounds on which to convict Dr. Amadou S Janneh. Or so I thought; rather, I hoped. I was holding our hope that at the very minimum; Dr. Janneh would come out this fracas wounded by the blatant abuse of his citizen rights, but still a free man. Dt Janneh.jpg

 

I was wrong; very wrong. Quite frankly, I was thrown way off guard by the allure of fair-play; charmed by some of the comments and observations Judge Emmanuel Nkea made during the trial. But these turned out to be mere rhetorical flourishes weaved in sadistic deception and delivered with provincial embellishment to project a false sense of fairness. Read more

Civil Society Associations Gambia Campaigned Against President Jammeh AU Candidacy!

  • News Item
  • January 26, 2012

 

CCG.jpg

Thursday, January 24, 2011

GAMBIAN CIVIL SOCIETY GROUPS AND PARTNERS CAUTION AGAINST A PRESIDENT YAHYA JAMMEH AFRICAN UNION CHAIRMANSHIP

Your Excellencies,

On the eve of the African Union Summit to be held in Addis Ababa, Ethiopia, on the 29th and 30th January, we the undersigned Gambian Civil Society Groupsi, regional and international partners in the struggle for human rights, democracy and free expression in The Gambia, humbly petition your august body, the Assembly of the Heads of State and Government, representing the member countries of the African Union not to elect President Yayha Jammeh of The Gambia, as chairman of the African Union.Ndey.jpgBanka1.jpg

 It has been brought to our attention that according to the rules of procedure of the Assembly, the Heads of State during the January Summit should elect one of their peers to assume the rotating Chairmanship of the Union. We are also aware that in 2012, West Africa has the chairperson responsibility and that President Yahya Jammeh, of The Gambia has declared his candidature. Read details 

 Click on link for details http://www.gainako.com:2095/3rdparty/squirrelmail/src/webmail.php

Was Dr. Janneh acting? Exploring the Scattered Janneh case

  • News Item
  • January 26, 2012

By Archam Molengel, Sare Balebeh, The Gambia

Reflections from a Gambian citizen on the recent imprisonment of a former government information minister-Dr. Amadou Scattered Janneh will spend the rest of his life in prison, this, after a Gambian court found him and others guilty of attempting to overthrow the democratically eleceted government of President Yahya Jammeh.

Exploring the Scattered Janneh case 

I observed from the onset, how the trial started, reading very seriously the editorials, and the general trends in the news media. I wasn't supposed to be very occupied to miss the court reports about the case when I could not make it at the courts. Somehow, I had started to make up my mind after I allowed myself to be part of a spiritual flight that traverse across the cosmos urging the heart to doing things that are so passionate to itself. That moment, the moment, we, call love, yes or no. If someone can get kicked for speaking one's mind, rest assured, if Amadou Scattered Janneh, (scattered as they call him his native Gunjur) is there, his face will be kicked right on. And here is why? Read more

The 2012 Jammeh Inauguration - Opinion

  • News Item
  • January 25, 2012

By Fakebba j Samateh.

I learned with sadness and dismay that the chief Gambian cheat had given himself another five year term in the office, thus making a fourth five year term. Watching Yahya Jammeh's inauguration on televission would show any sensible thinking Gambian, what the true intentions of this Kanilai Monster are.

1. Jammeh came to power accusing the Jawara administration of staying too long in power thus encouraging rampant corruption and mismanagement of public funds.
2. Jammeh said he hates politics because all politicians are hypocrites for they always lie to people promising what they cannot do.
3.Maybe Gambians either did not know or they keep pretending they don't know. How many of you have ever visited Kanilai? Yesterday Kanilai and today Kanilai are like earth and heaven for Kanilai is turning into a Dubai with Banks and hotels also the president has built a semi stadium now called the cultural square.

Full Text of President Obama's State of The Union Address 2012

  • News Item
  • January 25, 2012

 Obama1.bmp

President Obama's State of the Union Address 2012

"So it is with America. Each time I look at that flag, I’m reminded that our destiny is stitched together like those fifty stars and those thirteen stripes. No one built this country on their own. This Nation is great because we built it together. This Nation is great because we worked as a team. This Nation is great because we get each other’s backs. And if we hold fast to that truth, in this moment of trial, there is no challenge too great; no mission too hard. As long as we’re joined in common purpose, as long as we maintain our common resolve, our journey moves forward, our future is hopeful, and the state of our Union will always be strong".  Read full text

STGDP has elected a new Executive for 2012!

  • News Item
  • January 25, 2012

A_Jallow.jpgBanak Mmah.jpg

Press Release:

In accordance with the organizational by-laws, the general membership of Save the Gambia Democracy Project (STGDP) elected a Management Committee to run the affairs of the organization for the next two years on Saturday January 21, 2012.  The Management Committee comprises of six officials as: Chairperson, Vice Chairperson, Secretary General, Public Relations Officer, Treasurer, and Political Strategist At-large. Listed below are the newly elected Management Committee members: Banka Manneh of Atlanta Metro Area (Georgia, USA) was elected to extend his term as Chairman of STGDP. Banka's relentless demeanor and hard work, commitment and top notch leadership has proven to be a tremendous asset for the organization.


Subscribe via RSS

Recent Blogs

All Our Sponsors